Keep checks and balances in House

Print Article

Should your Montana House of Representatives move away from Constitutional Republic?

There has been some discussion on lowering the standards for Montana House rules from super majorities to simple (51 percent) majorities for the upcoming 66th legislative session all in the name of democracy. The problem is, we are not a democracy. The wisdom of our founders saw the danger in having straight majority rule. When the government starts talking about consolidating power (which moving more power to a simple majority is consolidation) the people of Montana always end up the victims.

America’s and Montana’s political system was set up as a Constitutional Republic. To quote the pledge, “to the Republic for which it stands”. We currently need super majorities to modify our constitution. We need three-fourths of the Legislature to spend the coal tax fund. We have a U.S. Senate that skews representation to rural states like Montana. We have an Electoral College that gives Montana voters three times more say than a California voter. We have three branches of state government that provide checks and balances. It takes two-thirds majority vote to override a governor’s veto. The list of super majorities in our governmental system are many.

In conjunction with these high standards, there are simple 51 percent majority standards, too. As a Republic, the Constitution provides for a healthy mix of power delegated to both the majority and minority.

Why do we have super majorities? To protect the minority idea. Our Constitutional Republic was set up so legislation should move slow and deliberate. It was set up to prevent tyranny of the majority. Since our founding there have been efforts to erode that Constitutional Republic and make government “easier” by moving toward democracy.

The word “fair” has been used to explain changing our Montana House rules to 51 percent. Is it fair to have the majority that fully controls the minority or should the minority have a voice?

Both parties have had policy or ideas that have been a casualty of the high standards of our Republic. Do we really want to deconstruct the system to get poorly crafted law passed? This goes way beyond partisanship. It goes to the heart of how fairly an idea is treated. The political landscape swings back and forth. One day you are in the majority the next day you are not.

Let’s keep our checks and balances. Let’s keep the power dispersed proportionally. Let’s keep a voice for all Montanans. Let’s keep with the wisdom of our founders and keep our Constitutional Republic.

—Rep. Matt Regier, HD4; Rep. Carl Glimm, HD6; Rep. John Fuller, HD8; Rep. David Dunn, HD9; Rep. Mark Noland, HD10, Rep. Derek Skees HD11

Print Article

Read More Letters to the Editor

Letters to the editor Jan. 14

January 14, 2019 at 11:44 am | Daily Inter Lake Can’t muzzle Montana citizens The proposed CSKT Water Compact (S. 262 bloated up in Sen. Tester’s Senate Bill 3013) violates the U.S. Constitution, Montana Constitution, and CSKT Tribal Constitution...

Comments

Read More

Preserving free elections is everyone’s business

January 14, 2019 at 11:44 am | Daily Inter Lake Free and fair elections are not partisan issues. Whether it’s imposing poll taxes in the Jim Crow South or rigging voting machines in Richard Daley’s Chicago, whenever public officials use the pow...

Comments

Read More

Letters to the editor Jan. 13

January 13, 2019 at 6:00 am | Daily Inter Lake Medicare equals disaster for all Sunday’s Jan. 6 letters to the editor section featured an opinion by Edd Blackler of Bigfork who extolled “Medicare for all” as a panacea for the health-care system....

Comments

Read More

Get our government operating again

January 13, 2019 at 6:00 am | Daily Inter Lake As all of us are too painfully aware, we are in the midst of another government shutdown to the immediate detriment of about 800,000 individuals — 420,000 working temporarily without pay and 380,00...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

News: (406) 837-5131
Advertising: 406-758-4410
Bigfork Eagle
c/o Daily Inter Lake
PO Box 7610
Kalispell, MT 59904

©2019 Bigfork Eagle Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X