Holmquist urges no vote on CSKT water compact

This will be the most significant and far-reaching decision this legislature has ever made, setting precedence not only in Montana but every state in the union. The question is — will our representatives represent our best interest as citizens of Montana, or will they buy into the scare tactics of litigation?

It will be a tough decision, as it seems that our governor and attorney general have already decided that Montana should relinquish water rights to the federal government to hold in trust for the tribe. My hope is that the proposed compact can be revised to identify the Salish and Kootenai Tribes’ reserved water rights on the reservation, while protecting the water rights of citizens off the reservation.

I have attended several meetings and received volumes of information on the tribal water compact, as well as various opinions from attorneys and hydrologists on both sides of the issue. The one thing that the attorneys seem to agree on is that off-reservation water rights have never been granted before, nor have they ever been adjudicated in a court of law.

While no one looks forward to litigation, I don’t believe that a “right to take fish” equates to a “water right.” It’s been portrayed that off-reservation water rights are not a new type of water right, yet it certainly seems that way.

I would encourage individuals to look at the water compact appendices on the Montana Department of Natural Resources and Conservation’s Web site. The compact itself gives some overview, but the appendices give a more in-depth look at the effects of the compact.

Flathead County, as well as other counties and the state of Montana, have much to lose if this compact is passed by the legislature. This will be detrimental to our property values, economy, property rights and way of life. Please contact your representatives and urge them to vote no on the Salish and Kootenai Tribes water compact.

Pam Holmquist, R-Evergreen, is a Flathead County Commissioner.

The Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes water rights compact has been sent to the 2015 Montana Legislature. Now it will be up to our representatives to defend our most precious commodity, our water.

This will be the most significant and far-reaching decision this legislature has ever made, setting precedence not only in Montana but every state in the union. The question is — will our representatives represent our best interest as citizens of Montana, or will they buy into the scare tactics of litigation?

It will be a tough decision, as it seems that our governor and attorney general have already decided that Montana should relinquish water rights to the federal government to hold in trust for the tribe. My hope is that the proposed compact can be revised to identify the Salish and Kootenai Tribes’ reserved water rights on the reservation, while protecting the water rights of citizens off the reservation.

I have attended several meetings and received volumes of information on the tribal water compact, as well as various opinions from attorneys and hydrologists on both sides of the issue. The one thing that the attorneys seem to agree on is that off-reservation water rights have never been granted before, nor have they ever been adjudicated in a court of law.

While no one looks forward to litigation, I don’t believe that a “right to take fish” equates to a “water right.” It’s been portrayed that off-reservation water rights are not a new type of water right, yet it certainly seems that way.

I would encourage individuals to look at the water compact appendices on the Montana Department of Natural Resources and Conservation’s Web site. The compact itself gives some overview, but the appendices give a more in-depth look at the effects of the compact.

Flathead County, as well as other counties and the state of Montana, have much to lose if this compact is passed by the legislature. This will be detrimental to our property values, economy, property rights and way of life. Please contact your representatives and urge them to vote no on the Salish and Kootenai Tribes water compact.

Pam Holmquist, R-Evergreen, is a Flathead County Commissioner.